Plausible reason for gold-digging antWhat could make an insect race intelligent?Sapient Ant Colony Rivaling...
Book where a space ship journeys to the center of the galaxy to find all the stars had gone supernova
I have trouble understanding this fallacy: "If A, then B. Therefore if not-B, then not-A."
Why is it that Bernie Sanders is always called a "socialist"?
Non-Cancer terminal illness that can affect young (age 10-13) girls?
After checking in online, how do I know whether I need to go show my passport at airport check-in?
Do authors have to be politically correct in article-writing?
What is a good reason for every spaceship to carry a weapon on board?
Why do all the books in Game of Thrones library have their covers facing the back of the shelf?
Taking headphones when quitting job
Does the US government have any planning in place to ensure there's no shortages of food, fuel, steel and other commodities?
The No-Straight Maze
Why avoid shared user accounts?
What game did these black and yellow dice come from?
How is it possible that the folder is there yet isnt in the same time?
How to delete duplicate text from a file?
What senses are available to a corpse subjected to a Speak with Dead spell?
Count repetitions of an array
What does an unprocessed RAW file look like?
What's this assembly doing?
Best way to strengthen a wheel?
Methods for writing a code review
What to do with threats of blacklisting?
Am I correct in stating that the study of topology is purely theoretical?
Why zero tolerance on nudity in space?
Plausible reason for gold-digging ant
What could make an insect race intelligent?Sapient Ant Colony Rivaling Homo Sapiens and Homo Neanderthal?Evolution of a naturally invisible predatorHow smart can I make ants?Mermaid Buoyancy: Oily Livers, Swim Bladders and LungsHow can a ninetails shape-shift in a more natural illusionary way without magic or supernatural stuff?Could Bamboos Evolve Into Trees In the Past?Purpose of Engineered Organic Flying WhalesWould there be any major disadvantages for a species to have six legs instead of four?Why would dragons who predates humans hoard gold?
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would this behavior serve?
biology creature-design evolution mythical-creatures insects
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would this behavior serve?
biology creature-design evolution mythical-creatures insects
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
2
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would this behavior serve?
biology creature-design evolution mythical-creatures insects
$endgroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would this behavior serve?
biology creature-design evolution mythical-creatures insects
biology creature-design evolution mythical-creatures insects
edited yesterday
Sherwood Botsford
6,930733
6,930733
asked yesterday
SealBoiSealBoi
6,04912263
6,04912263
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
2
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
2
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
2
2
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
5
5
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago
add a comment |
12 Answers
12
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would
this behavior serve?
It makes their chimneys work better.
The workers gather the gold and bring it to the colony. The soldiers use their large powerfull mandibles to shape the soft gold into roughly flat flakes which they distribute around the nest site.
The gold's reflection of the sun's light and heat in an upwards direction has two effects:
- It heats the chimneys, encouraging convection and allowing air circulation around the ant's farmed food source - the fungus below.

Attribution BBC 2019
- It reflects the heat off the surrounding ground, allowing it to be cool - enabling the underground tunnels used for farming the food fungus to expand and grow and thus the colony to be bigger and more succesfull.

Attribution: Darwin's Toolkit by UW–Madison CALS 2019
$endgroup$
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They don't value the Gold - They expel it from their burrows
What use is a shiny metal to an ant? They don't make artefacts or have currency. They don't have an aesthetic sense apart from food.
The ants line their burrows with a sticky substance they produce from their rear ends. Obviously a lump of gold is an obstruction to the building of their underground kingdoms.
They discard these annoying lumps of useless metal by bringing them to the surface and abandoning them there. If humans remove this refuse then so much the better.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Electrical conduction
Gold is a good conductor. Perhaps these ants use electrical pulses (rather than pheromones) to communicate in their nests. So they move the gold so that there are paths wherever they need them. They might also evolve special "router" ants that serve as junctions between paths. So the central pheromone unit (CPU) can send pulses that only reach specific sets of ants. Each ant could be identified by an instead of pheromone (IP) number.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
The ants are giant packrats!
The gold digging ants are not typical ants,
http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/the-monstrous-ant-of-the-medieval-bestiary/
There are also ants that, according to some bestiaries, live in
Ethiopia or India, are the size of dogs, and dig up gold from sand,
guard it, and pursue anything that tries to steal it, especially
greedy humans. Artists depicted these ants not as larger versions of
the familiar-looking insects, but more like actual dogs.

http://www.terrierman.com/goldenant.htm
The mountain ant
In ancient Persian the word for marmot was "mountain ant". And the
mountain ants do indeed dig up gold on occasion.
https://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/25/world/himalayas-offer-clue-to-legend-of-gold-digging-ants.html
Now a team of explorers says it has solved the puzzle. The explorers
believe they have pinpointed the land of the legendary gold-digging
ants and the people who profited in one of the most inaccessible
regions of the Himalayas along the upper Indus River.
They say the outsize furry ''ants,'' first described by Herodotus in
the fifth century B.C., are in fact big marmots. These creatures --
Herodotus calls them ''bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog''
-- are still throwing up gold-bearing soil from deep underground as they dig their burrows. Most important, the explorers say they have
found indigenous people on the same high plateau who say that for
generations they have collected gold dust from the marmots' work.
Here is a colony of these big marmots.

https://www.kathmanduandbeyond.com/feeding-himalayan-marmots-ladakh-india/
But these marmots don't care about the gold. They just bring it up. Why would a rodent care about shiny gold nuggets enough to hoard them and even fight for them? There is one rodent that does. Packrats!
https://nuggetshooter.blog/2018/01/31/pack-rat-gold/
That morning as the horse and mule were loaded Tucker noticed a hole
in his saddlebag with gold dust spilling from it and cussing that rat
for chewing into the bag he began unpacking to save his precious gold,
but it was gone…Only the fine gold that hadn’t spilled from the pouch
into the saddlebag after being chewed apart by the packrat remained.
All of the nuggets were gone as well as his pocket watch, and other
objects small enough for the critter to haul off.
So: your "ants" are colony dwelling, burrowing rodents with a packrat-like habit of hoarding neat things, especially shiny things. In the above linked article, the prospector who lost his gold to the rat spent several days digging into burrows trying to find the one where his gold was, without luck. The article concludes by speculating that in an area naturally rich in gold nuggets, resident packrats might accumulate nuggets over time, giving rise to nugget troves in ancient rodent dens.
I am not sure a marmot would charge a guy with a sword like the ones above are doing but I would not want to test them. They are pretty big one at a time, marmots.
@chasly from UK pointed out that this answer does not cover the evolutionary angle; true. And a downvote for this lack - horrors! I was unable to find any thing written about why packrats might favor shiny things for their nests. I have taken this speculation on myself.
Packrats like to incorporate shiny things into their nests - this is well known.
Packrats like to use old nests if they can find them. It makes sense - if a nest has long been inhabited that means it is a good place for packrats. Plus older nests are more substantial, in part because of...
Amberrat.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralaustralia/8419933870

Rats and especially packrats urinate onto their nests. Over time the accumulated urine can crystallize, cementing the nest material together into shiny masses called amberrat. These cemented nests are durable and of use to paleontologists, as the preserved materials record eras past.
Thus we have selective advantage for rats that like old nests, and old rat nests tend to be shiny. This could mean a selective advantage for rats who like shiny nests. Such rats will make their nests shiny if given materials to do so because they like shiny nests. Gold nuggets are definitely shiny. Thus - selective advantage for "ants" that seek out gold and incorporate it into their nest.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I cant find a good source, but gold found in streams are supposed to be created by bacteria that are allergic to gold. They use mechanisms to make the water stop retaining the gold so it drops to the floor of the riverbed.
Your ants have larvae that are allergic to gold. They might not die from it, but its not good for them. The ants have evolved to actively dig up the gold and drag it to specific area's where larvae will not be living, and the ants who do the digging and dragging will avoid contact with larvae and ants that care for them.
Edit: found source. https://www.businessinsider.com/bacteria-creates-microscopic-gold-nuggets-2013-2?international=true&r=US&IR=T
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Sex
First, I'll assume that, as per other answers, we're not actually talking about ants, but rather large(ish) mammals.
Rather than take the packrat route, let's go with bowerbirds. The males build elaborate courtship structures, and decorate them with colorful objects. The satin bowerbird, for instance, is partial to blue.
So, if a species of "ants" has females which are partial to shiny, males will collect and display shiny objects - such as gold nuggets. Furthermore, deep digging which brings up pieces of gold will also be selected for.
It's amazing the number of behaviors which can ultimately be explained by sex.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They live on a planet close to an X-ray star. A layer of heavy metals in their integument gives them some resistance to radiation.
They were engineered this way by a race that lusts for gold. The ants actually eat it, dissolve it in an internal equivalent of Aqua Regia, and plate it out on their integument.
The original species was much less discriminating and would use lead, cadmium, platinum, osmium -- almost any heavy nucleus.
Periodically the engineers land and release a pheromone that brings the ants to collection jars where they are flash burned, and the metal taken for further processing.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Gold helps with their Farming
They don't bring gold to the surface and "throw it outside", but they could bring it into their fungus farms, where it could either:
- Repel harmful bacteria or organisms that would otherwise harm their farms.
- Attract & grow beneficial bacteria or organisms.
Some metals in our world exhibit an oligodynamic effect ("a chemical substance or microorganism intended to destroy, deter, render harmless, or exert a controlling effect on any harmful organism by chemical or biological means" [1]), including gold.
Apparently stainless steel is terrible at inhibiting bacteria, while brass would be much safer, in a hospital for example.
Some ants in our world have been farming fungus for millions of years, and apparently some people are wondering how they manage to avoid devastation by disease or parasites (like what happened to the Big Mike bananas).
And so in this other world there could be ants that farm a particular type of crop that either thrives on or around gold, or the gold repels a particularly nasty organism that would otherwise devastate their crops.
[The gold might not even affect their crop directly, but could be a link in a chain, like preventing a bacteria that would feed another fungus, that would feed another organism or predator, that would destroy the ants' crop or the ants themselves. Imagine a truffle-hunting pig (or elephant) that destroys everything in it's search.]
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Dummy gold war
They are exceptionally clever ants. When they find gold, they plant it on the anthill of they enemy and wait for a human to see it and destroy their enemy.
Very effective.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Ants (of any size) communicate largely through pheromones - everything from mating to directions. As it happens, these ants also communicate through pheromones, but something about properties unique to gold either scrambles or removes the pheromone signals. Instinctively realizing that gold, therefore, is quite dangerous, the ants would thus attempt to remove the gold from their burrows, and depending on the strength of the effect, they may even hunt for gold and collect it to keep from being influenced.
Normal ants often have "garbage rooms" where they store their dead, as well as other garbage produced by the hill and its occupants, which would make a fine place to store excavated gold. They may even try to protect this gold, as their instincts have taught them that other creatures can use the gold to disorganize them.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
It's a result of Darwinian evolution. Ant colonies that expelled gold to the surface, for whatever reasons, naturally attracted humans to them. Humans have a proclivity for carrying food and water with them when they journey through the desert. Gold-laden dirt would be relatively heavy, so humans intending to collect the dirt and return it to civilization for refining would tend to leave an equivalent amount of mass behind. This jetsam would frequently contain consumables such as food and water that would no longer be needed due to the interrupted travel plans of the fortunate discoverer. Those ant colonies would be more likely to successfully spread deeper into areas of desert that would otherwise be too inhospitable for them.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Their large size is the key.
These very large ants will only dig their mounds out of the sides of mountains, hills and cliffs. The geographical area contains a large deposits of quartz over several square miles, and there is less chance of a tunnel collapse inside a quartz mountain.
Gold is found in quartz deposits, and the ants can dig out the gold far easier than quartz because it's a soft metal.
So where there are ants, there is gold by the entrance to their quartz caves.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "579"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f139922%2fplausible-reason-for-gold-digging-ant%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
12 Answers
12
active
oldest
votes
12 Answers
12
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would
this behavior serve?
It makes their chimneys work better.
The workers gather the gold and bring it to the colony. The soldiers use their large powerfull mandibles to shape the soft gold into roughly flat flakes which they distribute around the nest site.
The gold's reflection of the sun's light and heat in an upwards direction has two effects:
- It heats the chimneys, encouraging convection and allowing air circulation around the ant's farmed food source - the fungus below.

Attribution BBC 2019
- It reflects the heat off the surrounding ground, allowing it to be cool - enabling the underground tunnels used for farming the food fungus to expand and grow and thus the colony to be bigger and more succesfull.

Attribution: Darwin's Toolkit by UW–Madison CALS 2019
$endgroup$
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would
this behavior serve?
It makes their chimneys work better.
The workers gather the gold and bring it to the colony. The soldiers use their large powerfull mandibles to shape the soft gold into roughly flat flakes which they distribute around the nest site.
The gold's reflection of the sun's light and heat in an upwards direction has two effects:
- It heats the chimneys, encouraging convection and allowing air circulation around the ant's farmed food source - the fungus below.

Attribution BBC 2019
- It reflects the heat off the surrounding ground, allowing it to be cool - enabling the underground tunnels used for farming the food fungus to expand and grow and thus the colony to be bigger and more succesfull.

Attribution: Darwin's Toolkit by UW–Madison CALS 2019
$endgroup$
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would
this behavior serve?
It makes their chimneys work better.
The workers gather the gold and bring it to the colony. The soldiers use their large powerfull mandibles to shape the soft gold into roughly flat flakes which they distribute around the nest site.
The gold's reflection of the sun's light and heat in an upwards direction has two effects:
- It heats the chimneys, encouraging convection and allowing air circulation around the ant's farmed food source - the fungus below.

Attribution BBC 2019
- It reflects the heat off the surrounding ground, allowing it to be cool - enabling the underground tunnels used for farming the food fungus to expand and grow and thus the colony to be bigger and more succesfull.

Attribution: Darwin's Toolkit by UW–Madison CALS 2019
$endgroup$
Why would ants unearth pieces of gold? What evolutionary purpose would
this behavior serve?
It makes their chimneys work better.
The workers gather the gold and bring it to the colony. The soldiers use their large powerfull mandibles to shape the soft gold into roughly flat flakes which they distribute around the nest site.
The gold's reflection of the sun's light and heat in an upwards direction has two effects:
- It heats the chimneys, encouraging convection and allowing air circulation around the ant's farmed food source - the fungus below.

Attribution BBC 2019
- It reflects the heat off the surrounding ground, allowing it to be cool - enabling the underground tunnels used for farming the food fungus to expand and grow and thus the colony to be bigger and more succesfull.

Attribution: Darwin's Toolkit by UW–Madison CALS 2019
answered yesterday
AgrajagAgrajag
4,858837
4,858837
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
add a comment |
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
12
12
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
+1 For not derailing the question by assuming it wasn't actually ants. It's also a good answer.
$endgroup$
– Cyn
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Cyn Thanks, was tempted to synonymise "ant" with "Umpa-Lumpa" or "mine worker", but there's lithium in the water here.
$endgroup$
– Agrajag
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
fossil hunters actually check ant mounds for fossil teeth because ants prefer he hardest material they can find to make their mount tops out of, in many places that equals fossilized teeth. so it is definitely possible for them to at least use gold ore for better conductive ability in cooling tunnels.
$endgroup$
– John
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
$begingroup$
Also, as gold is one of the most malleable metals, if any type of small animal wanted to build something out of metal by chewing it, it would be probably gold. Or lead, but lead would poison them, so they stick to gold.
$endgroup$
– vsz
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They don't value the Gold - They expel it from their burrows
What use is a shiny metal to an ant? They don't make artefacts or have currency. They don't have an aesthetic sense apart from food.
The ants line their burrows with a sticky substance they produce from their rear ends. Obviously a lump of gold is an obstruction to the building of their underground kingdoms.
They discard these annoying lumps of useless metal by bringing them to the surface and abandoning them there. If humans remove this refuse then so much the better.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They don't value the Gold - They expel it from their burrows
What use is a shiny metal to an ant? They don't make artefacts or have currency. They don't have an aesthetic sense apart from food.
The ants line their burrows with a sticky substance they produce from their rear ends. Obviously a lump of gold is an obstruction to the building of their underground kingdoms.
They discard these annoying lumps of useless metal by bringing them to the surface and abandoning them there. If humans remove this refuse then so much the better.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They don't value the Gold - They expel it from their burrows
What use is a shiny metal to an ant? They don't make artefacts or have currency. They don't have an aesthetic sense apart from food.
The ants line their burrows with a sticky substance they produce from their rear ends. Obviously a lump of gold is an obstruction to the building of their underground kingdoms.
They discard these annoying lumps of useless metal by bringing them to the surface and abandoning them there. If humans remove this refuse then so much the better.
$endgroup$
They don't value the Gold - They expel it from their burrows
What use is a shiny metal to an ant? They don't make artefacts or have currency. They don't have an aesthetic sense apart from food.
The ants line their burrows with a sticky substance they produce from their rear ends. Obviously a lump of gold is an obstruction to the building of their underground kingdoms.
They discard these annoying lumps of useless metal by bringing them to the surface and abandoning them there. If humans remove this refuse then so much the better.
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
chasly from UKchasly from UK
17.2k776151
17.2k776151
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
add a comment |
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
$begingroup$
Boom. Might not require them to seek out and dig up gold, but it’s what an ant would likely do, especially if the gold doesn’t react with something the ants need it to react to.
$endgroup$
– Joe Bloggs
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
$begingroup$
But then wouldn't the ant expel all obstructive substances such as metals / rocks / ores etc. therefore not really sorting out the gold.
$endgroup$
– colmde
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
@colmde - That's a fair point. The thing is that it is humans that notice the phenomenon. Ants in non-gold-bearing areas won't be noticed by people. Only the ants that fortuitously live in gold-rich deserts will become a source of human fascination.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Electrical conduction
Gold is a good conductor. Perhaps these ants use electrical pulses (rather than pheromones) to communicate in their nests. So they move the gold so that there are paths wherever they need them. They might also evolve special "router" ants that serve as junctions between paths. So the central pheromone unit (CPU) can send pulses that only reach specific sets of ants. Each ant could be identified by an instead of pheromone (IP) number.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Electrical conduction
Gold is a good conductor. Perhaps these ants use electrical pulses (rather than pheromones) to communicate in their nests. So they move the gold so that there are paths wherever they need them. They might also evolve special "router" ants that serve as junctions between paths. So the central pheromone unit (CPU) can send pulses that only reach specific sets of ants. Each ant could be identified by an instead of pheromone (IP) number.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Electrical conduction
Gold is a good conductor. Perhaps these ants use electrical pulses (rather than pheromones) to communicate in their nests. So they move the gold so that there are paths wherever they need them. They might also evolve special "router" ants that serve as junctions between paths. So the central pheromone unit (CPU) can send pulses that only reach specific sets of ants. Each ant could be identified by an instead of pheromone (IP) number.
$endgroup$
Electrical conduction
Gold is a good conductor. Perhaps these ants use electrical pulses (rather than pheromones) to communicate in their nests. So they move the gold so that there are paths wherever they need them. They might also evolve special "router" ants that serve as junctions between paths. So the central pheromone unit (CPU) can send pulses that only reach specific sets of ants. Each ant could be identified by an instead of pheromone (IP) number.
answered yesterday
BrythanBrythan
20.6k74285
20.6k74285
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
add a comment |
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
$begingroup$
Some types of ants seem to be attracted to electricity.
$endgroup$
– jamesdlin
yesterday
5
5
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
$begingroup$
Gold is usually preferred over other materials because it's very inert - it won't rust or corrode. So a moist, acidic, or otherwise chemically reactive environment would help to justify the ants' preference. And acid batteries would make excellent power sources! Central pheromone unit! Pure poetry. What if... the circuitry forms a complex computer system, and the colony is actually run by a sentient AI?! Then AI would stand for Ant Intelligence. I will see myself out.
$endgroup$
– BoomChuck
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
The ants are giant packrats!
The gold digging ants are not typical ants,
http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/the-monstrous-ant-of-the-medieval-bestiary/
There are also ants that, according to some bestiaries, live in
Ethiopia or India, are the size of dogs, and dig up gold from sand,
guard it, and pursue anything that tries to steal it, especially
greedy humans. Artists depicted these ants not as larger versions of
the familiar-looking insects, but more like actual dogs.

http://www.terrierman.com/goldenant.htm
The mountain ant
In ancient Persian the word for marmot was "mountain ant". And the
mountain ants do indeed dig up gold on occasion.
https://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/25/world/himalayas-offer-clue-to-legend-of-gold-digging-ants.html
Now a team of explorers says it has solved the puzzle. The explorers
believe they have pinpointed the land of the legendary gold-digging
ants and the people who profited in one of the most inaccessible
regions of the Himalayas along the upper Indus River.
They say the outsize furry ''ants,'' first described by Herodotus in
the fifth century B.C., are in fact big marmots. These creatures --
Herodotus calls them ''bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog''
-- are still throwing up gold-bearing soil from deep underground as they dig their burrows. Most important, the explorers say they have
found indigenous people on the same high plateau who say that for
generations they have collected gold dust from the marmots' work.
Here is a colony of these big marmots.

https://www.kathmanduandbeyond.com/feeding-himalayan-marmots-ladakh-india/
But these marmots don't care about the gold. They just bring it up. Why would a rodent care about shiny gold nuggets enough to hoard them and even fight for them? There is one rodent that does. Packrats!
https://nuggetshooter.blog/2018/01/31/pack-rat-gold/
That morning as the horse and mule were loaded Tucker noticed a hole
in his saddlebag with gold dust spilling from it and cussing that rat
for chewing into the bag he began unpacking to save his precious gold,
but it was gone…Only the fine gold that hadn’t spilled from the pouch
into the saddlebag after being chewed apart by the packrat remained.
All of the nuggets were gone as well as his pocket watch, and other
objects small enough for the critter to haul off.
So: your "ants" are colony dwelling, burrowing rodents with a packrat-like habit of hoarding neat things, especially shiny things. In the above linked article, the prospector who lost his gold to the rat spent several days digging into burrows trying to find the one where his gold was, without luck. The article concludes by speculating that in an area naturally rich in gold nuggets, resident packrats might accumulate nuggets over time, giving rise to nugget troves in ancient rodent dens.
I am not sure a marmot would charge a guy with a sword like the ones above are doing but I would not want to test them. They are pretty big one at a time, marmots.
@chasly from UK pointed out that this answer does not cover the evolutionary angle; true. And a downvote for this lack - horrors! I was unable to find any thing written about why packrats might favor shiny things for their nests. I have taken this speculation on myself.
Packrats like to incorporate shiny things into their nests - this is well known.
Packrats like to use old nests if they can find them. It makes sense - if a nest has long been inhabited that means it is a good place for packrats. Plus older nests are more substantial, in part because of...
Amberrat.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralaustralia/8419933870

Rats and especially packrats urinate onto their nests. Over time the accumulated urine can crystallize, cementing the nest material together into shiny masses called amberrat. These cemented nests are durable and of use to paleontologists, as the preserved materials record eras past.
Thus we have selective advantage for rats that like old nests, and old rat nests tend to be shiny. This could mean a selective advantage for rats who like shiny nests. Such rats will make their nests shiny if given materials to do so because they like shiny nests. Gold nuggets are definitely shiny. Thus - selective advantage for "ants" that seek out gold and incorporate it into their nest.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
The ants are giant packrats!
The gold digging ants are not typical ants,
http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/the-monstrous-ant-of-the-medieval-bestiary/
There are also ants that, according to some bestiaries, live in
Ethiopia or India, are the size of dogs, and dig up gold from sand,
guard it, and pursue anything that tries to steal it, especially
greedy humans. Artists depicted these ants not as larger versions of
the familiar-looking insects, but more like actual dogs.

http://www.terrierman.com/goldenant.htm
The mountain ant
In ancient Persian the word for marmot was "mountain ant". And the
mountain ants do indeed dig up gold on occasion.
https://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/25/world/himalayas-offer-clue-to-legend-of-gold-digging-ants.html
Now a team of explorers says it has solved the puzzle. The explorers
believe they have pinpointed the land of the legendary gold-digging
ants and the people who profited in one of the most inaccessible
regions of the Himalayas along the upper Indus River.
They say the outsize furry ''ants,'' first described by Herodotus in
the fifth century B.C., are in fact big marmots. These creatures --
Herodotus calls them ''bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog''
-- are still throwing up gold-bearing soil from deep underground as they dig their burrows. Most important, the explorers say they have
found indigenous people on the same high plateau who say that for
generations they have collected gold dust from the marmots' work.
Here is a colony of these big marmots.

https://www.kathmanduandbeyond.com/feeding-himalayan-marmots-ladakh-india/
But these marmots don't care about the gold. They just bring it up. Why would a rodent care about shiny gold nuggets enough to hoard them and even fight for them? There is one rodent that does. Packrats!
https://nuggetshooter.blog/2018/01/31/pack-rat-gold/
That morning as the horse and mule were loaded Tucker noticed a hole
in his saddlebag with gold dust spilling from it and cussing that rat
for chewing into the bag he began unpacking to save his precious gold,
but it was gone…Only the fine gold that hadn’t spilled from the pouch
into the saddlebag after being chewed apart by the packrat remained.
All of the nuggets were gone as well as his pocket watch, and other
objects small enough for the critter to haul off.
So: your "ants" are colony dwelling, burrowing rodents with a packrat-like habit of hoarding neat things, especially shiny things. In the above linked article, the prospector who lost his gold to the rat spent several days digging into burrows trying to find the one where his gold was, without luck. The article concludes by speculating that in an area naturally rich in gold nuggets, resident packrats might accumulate nuggets over time, giving rise to nugget troves in ancient rodent dens.
I am not sure a marmot would charge a guy with a sword like the ones above are doing but I would not want to test them. They are pretty big one at a time, marmots.
@chasly from UK pointed out that this answer does not cover the evolutionary angle; true. And a downvote for this lack - horrors! I was unable to find any thing written about why packrats might favor shiny things for their nests. I have taken this speculation on myself.
Packrats like to incorporate shiny things into their nests - this is well known.
Packrats like to use old nests if they can find them. It makes sense - if a nest has long been inhabited that means it is a good place for packrats. Plus older nests are more substantial, in part because of...
Amberrat.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralaustralia/8419933870

Rats and especially packrats urinate onto their nests. Over time the accumulated urine can crystallize, cementing the nest material together into shiny masses called amberrat. These cemented nests are durable and of use to paleontologists, as the preserved materials record eras past.
Thus we have selective advantage for rats that like old nests, and old rat nests tend to be shiny. This could mean a selective advantage for rats who like shiny nests. Such rats will make their nests shiny if given materials to do so because they like shiny nests. Gold nuggets are definitely shiny. Thus - selective advantage for "ants" that seek out gold and incorporate it into their nest.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
The ants are giant packrats!
The gold digging ants are not typical ants,
http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/the-monstrous-ant-of-the-medieval-bestiary/
There are also ants that, according to some bestiaries, live in
Ethiopia or India, are the size of dogs, and dig up gold from sand,
guard it, and pursue anything that tries to steal it, especially
greedy humans. Artists depicted these ants not as larger versions of
the familiar-looking insects, but more like actual dogs.

http://www.terrierman.com/goldenant.htm
The mountain ant
In ancient Persian the word for marmot was "mountain ant". And the
mountain ants do indeed dig up gold on occasion.
https://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/25/world/himalayas-offer-clue-to-legend-of-gold-digging-ants.html
Now a team of explorers says it has solved the puzzle. The explorers
believe they have pinpointed the land of the legendary gold-digging
ants and the people who profited in one of the most inaccessible
regions of the Himalayas along the upper Indus River.
They say the outsize furry ''ants,'' first described by Herodotus in
the fifth century B.C., are in fact big marmots. These creatures --
Herodotus calls them ''bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog''
-- are still throwing up gold-bearing soil from deep underground as they dig their burrows. Most important, the explorers say they have
found indigenous people on the same high plateau who say that for
generations they have collected gold dust from the marmots' work.
Here is a colony of these big marmots.

https://www.kathmanduandbeyond.com/feeding-himalayan-marmots-ladakh-india/
But these marmots don't care about the gold. They just bring it up. Why would a rodent care about shiny gold nuggets enough to hoard them and even fight for them? There is one rodent that does. Packrats!
https://nuggetshooter.blog/2018/01/31/pack-rat-gold/
That morning as the horse and mule were loaded Tucker noticed a hole
in his saddlebag with gold dust spilling from it and cussing that rat
for chewing into the bag he began unpacking to save his precious gold,
but it was gone…Only the fine gold that hadn’t spilled from the pouch
into the saddlebag after being chewed apart by the packrat remained.
All of the nuggets were gone as well as his pocket watch, and other
objects small enough for the critter to haul off.
So: your "ants" are colony dwelling, burrowing rodents with a packrat-like habit of hoarding neat things, especially shiny things. In the above linked article, the prospector who lost his gold to the rat spent several days digging into burrows trying to find the one where his gold was, without luck. The article concludes by speculating that in an area naturally rich in gold nuggets, resident packrats might accumulate nuggets over time, giving rise to nugget troves in ancient rodent dens.
I am not sure a marmot would charge a guy with a sword like the ones above are doing but I would not want to test them. They are pretty big one at a time, marmots.
@chasly from UK pointed out that this answer does not cover the evolutionary angle; true. And a downvote for this lack - horrors! I was unable to find any thing written about why packrats might favor shiny things for their nests. I have taken this speculation on myself.
Packrats like to incorporate shiny things into their nests - this is well known.
Packrats like to use old nests if they can find them. It makes sense - if a nest has long been inhabited that means it is a good place for packrats. Plus older nests are more substantial, in part because of...
Amberrat.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralaustralia/8419933870

Rats and especially packrats urinate onto their nests. Over time the accumulated urine can crystallize, cementing the nest material together into shiny masses called amberrat. These cemented nests are durable and of use to paleontologists, as the preserved materials record eras past.
Thus we have selective advantage for rats that like old nests, and old rat nests tend to be shiny. This could mean a selective advantage for rats who like shiny nests. Such rats will make their nests shiny if given materials to do so because they like shiny nests. Gold nuggets are definitely shiny. Thus - selective advantage for "ants" that seek out gold and incorporate it into their nest.
$endgroup$
The ants are giant packrats!
The gold digging ants are not typical ants,
http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/the-monstrous-ant-of-the-medieval-bestiary/
There are also ants that, according to some bestiaries, live in
Ethiopia or India, are the size of dogs, and dig up gold from sand,
guard it, and pursue anything that tries to steal it, especially
greedy humans. Artists depicted these ants not as larger versions of
the familiar-looking insects, but more like actual dogs.

http://www.terrierman.com/goldenant.htm
The mountain ant
In ancient Persian the word for marmot was "mountain ant". And the
mountain ants do indeed dig up gold on occasion.
https://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/25/world/himalayas-offer-clue-to-legend-of-gold-digging-ants.html
Now a team of explorers says it has solved the puzzle. The explorers
believe they have pinpointed the land of the legendary gold-digging
ants and the people who profited in one of the most inaccessible
regions of the Himalayas along the upper Indus River.
They say the outsize furry ''ants,'' first described by Herodotus in
the fifth century B.C., are in fact big marmots. These creatures --
Herodotus calls them ''bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog''
-- are still throwing up gold-bearing soil from deep underground as they dig their burrows. Most important, the explorers say they have
found indigenous people on the same high plateau who say that for
generations they have collected gold dust from the marmots' work.
Here is a colony of these big marmots.

https://www.kathmanduandbeyond.com/feeding-himalayan-marmots-ladakh-india/
But these marmots don't care about the gold. They just bring it up. Why would a rodent care about shiny gold nuggets enough to hoard them and even fight for them? There is one rodent that does. Packrats!
https://nuggetshooter.blog/2018/01/31/pack-rat-gold/
That morning as the horse and mule were loaded Tucker noticed a hole
in his saddlebag with gold dust spilling from it and cussing that rat
for chewing into the bag he began unpacking to save his precious gold,
but it was gone…Only the fine gold that hadn’t spilled from the pouch
into the saddlebag after being chewed apart by the packrat remained.
All of the nuggets were gone as well as his pocket watch, and other
objects small enough for the critter to haul off.
So: your "ants" are colony dwelling, burrowing rodents with a packrat-like habit of hoarding neat things, especially shiny things. In the above linked article, the prospector who lost his gold to the rat spent several days digging into burrows trying to find the one where his gold was, without luck. The article concludes by speculating that in an area naturally rich in gold nuggets, resident packrats might accumulate nuggets over time, giving rise to nugget troves in ancient rodent dens.
I am not sure a marmot would charge a guy with a sword like the ones above are doing but I would not want to test them. They are pretty big one at a time, marmots.
@chasly from UK pointed out that this answer does not cover the evolutionary angle; true. And a downvote for this lack - horrors! I was unable to find any thing written about why packrats might favor shiny things for their nests. I have taken this speculation on myself.
Packrats like to incorporate shiny things into their nests - this is well known.
Packrats like to use old nests if they can find them. It makes sense - if a nest has long been inhabited that means it is a good place for packrats. Plus older nests are more substantial, in part because of...
Amberrat.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/centralaustralia/8419933870

Rats and especially packrats urinate onto their nests. Over time the accumulated urine can crystallize, cementing the nest material together into shiny masses called amberrat. These cemented nests are durable and of use to paleontologists, as the preserved materials record eras past.
Thus we have selective advantage for rats that like old nests, and old rat nests tend to be shiny. This could mean a selective advantage for rats who like shiny nests. Such rats will make their nests shiny if given materials to do so because they like shiny nests. Gold nuggets are definitely shiny. Thus - selective advantage for "ants" that seek out gold and incorporate it into their nest.
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
WillkWillk
109k26205458
109k26205458
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
This is one most excellent piece of research!
$endgroup$
– AlexP
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
Excellent and fascinating piece of research! It gives a possible origin of the myth but doesn't actually answer the question as asked though.
$endgroup$
– chasly from UK
yesterday
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
$begingroup$
I love the photo of the fat-ass marmots! Heh!
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I cant find a good source, but gold found in streams are supposed to be created by bacteria that are allergic to gold. They use mechanisms to make the water stop retaining the gold so it drops to the floor of the riverbed.
Your ants have larvae that are allergic to gold. They might not die from it, but its not good for them. The ants have evolved to actively dig up the gold and drag it to specific area's where larvae will not be living, and the ants who do the digging and dragging will avoid contact with larvae and ants that care for them.
Edit: found source. https://www.businessinsider.com/bacteria-creates-microscopic-gold-nuggets-2013-2?international=true&r=US&IR=T
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I cant find a good source, but gold found in streams are supposed to be created by bacteria that are allergic to gold. They use mechanisms to make the water stop retaining the gold so it drops to the floor of the riverbed.
Your ants have larvae that are allergic to gold. They might not die from it, but its not good for them. The ants have evolved to actively dig up the gold and drag it to specific area's where larvae will not be living, and the ants who do the digging and dragging will avoid contact with larvae and ants that care for them.
Edit: found source. https://www.businessinsider.com/bacteria-creates-microscopic-gold-nuggets-2013-2?international=true&r=US&IR=T
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I cant find a good source, but gold found in streams are supposed to be created by bacteria that are allergic to gold. They use mechanisms to make the water stop retaining the gold so it drops to the floor of the riverbed.
Your ants have larvae that are allergic to gold. They might not die from it, but its not good for them. The ants have evolved to actively dig up the gold and drag it to specific area's where larvae will not be living, and the ants who do the digging and dragging will avoid contact with larvae and ants that care for them.
Edit: found source. https://www.businessinsider.com/bacteria-creates-microscopic-gold-nuggets-2013-2?international=true&r=US&IR=T
$endgroup$
I cant find a good source, but gold found in streams are supposed to be created by bacteria that are allergic to gold. They use mechanisms to make the water stop retaining the gold so it drops to the floor of the riverbed.
Your ants have larvae that are allergic to gold. They might not die from it, but its not good for them. The ants have evolved to actively dig up the gold and drag it to specific area's where larvae will not be living, and the ants who do the digging and dragging will avoid contact with larvae and ants that care for them.
Edit: found source. https://www.businessinsider.com/bacteria-creates-microscopic-gold-nuggets-2013-2?international=true&r=US&IR=T
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
DemiganDemigan
9,4031945
9,4031945
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Sex
First, I'll assume that, as per other answers, we're not actually talking about ants, but rather large(ish) mammals.
Rather than take the packrat route, let's go with bowerbirds. The males build elaborate courtship structures, and decorate them with colorful objects. The satin bowerbird, for instance, is partial to blue.
So, if a species of "ants" has females which are partial to shiny, males will collect and display shiny objects - such as gold nuggets. Furthermore, deep digging which brings up pieces of gold will also be selected for.
It's amazing the number of behaviors which can ultimately be explained by sex.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Sex
First, I'll assume that, as per other answers, we're not actually talking about ants, but rather large(ish) mammals.
Rather than take the packrat route, let's go with bowerbirds. The males build elaborate courtship structures, and decorate them with colorful objects. The satin bowerbird, for instance, is partial to blue.
So, if a species of "ants" has females which are partial to shiny, males will collect and display shiny objects - such as gold nuggets. Furthermore, deep digging which brings up pieces of gold will also be selected for.
It's amazing the number of behaviors which can ultimately be explained by sex.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Sex
First, I'll assume that, as per other answers, we're not actually talking about ants, but rather large(ish) mammals.
Rather than take the packrat route, let's go with bowerbirds. The males build elaborate courtship structures, and decorate them with colorful objects. The satin bowerbird, for instance, is partial to blue.
So, if a species of "ants" has females which are partial to shiny, males will collect and display shiny objects - such as gold nuggets. Furthermore, deep digging which brings up pieces of gold will also be selected for.
It's amazing the number of behaviors which can ultimately be explained by sex.
$endgroup$
Sex
First, I'll assume that, as per other answers, we're not actually talking about ants, but rather large(ish) mammals.
Rather than take the packrat route, let's go with bowerbirds. The males build elaborate courtship structures, and decorate them with colorful objects. The satin bowerbird, for instance, is partial to blue.
So, if a species of "ants" has females which are partial to shiny, males will collect and display shiny objects - such as gold nuggets. Furthermore, deep digging which brings up pieces of gold will also be selected for.
It's amazing the number of behaviors which can ultimately be explained by sex.
answered yesterday
WhatRoughBeastWhatRoughBeast
23.2k23280
23.2k23280
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
Agreed. It's amazing how well known natural selection is, and sexual selection is almost unknown, even though it's more important in some cases. For instance, humans almost all the time survive until breeding age, but having children and spreading their genes is completely different matter.
$endgroup$
– Nyos
12 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
$begingroup$
@Nyos - My own school days are long gone, but I remember in grade school reading about the Irish Elk, and being singularly unimpressed by the explanation of their enormous antlers as some sort of genetic overshoot. It was sexual selection all the way, baby.
$endgroup$
– WhatRoughBeast
11 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They live on a planet close to an X-ray star. A layer of heavy metals in their integument gives them some resistance to radiation.
They were engineered this way by a race that lusts for gold. The ants actually eat it, dissolve it in an internal equivalent of Aqua Regia, and plate it out on their integument.
The original species was much less discriminating and would use lead, cadmium, platinum, osmium -- almost any heavy nucleus.
Periodically the engineers land and release a pheromone that brings the ants to collection jars where they are flash burned, and the metal taken for further processing.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They live on a planet close to an X-ray star. A layer of heavy metals in their integument gives them some resistance to radiation.
They were engineered this way by a race that lusts for gold. The ants actually eat it, dissolve it in an internal equivalent of Aqua Regia, and plate it out on their integument.
The original species was much less discriminating and would use lead, cadmium, platinum, osmium -- almost any heavy nucleus.
Periodically the engineers land and release a pheromone that brings the ants to collection jars where they are flash burned, and the metal taken for further processing.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
They live on a planet close to an X-ray star. A layer of heavy metals in their integument gives them some resistance to radiation.
They were engineered this way by a race that lusts for gold. The ants actually eat it, dissolve it in an internal equivalent of Aqua Regia, and plate it out on their integument.
The original species was much less discriminating and would use lead, cadmium, platinum, osmium -- almost any heavy nucleus.
Periodically the engineers land and release a pheromone that brings the ants to collection jars where they are flash burned, and the metal taken for further processing.
$endgroup$
They live on a planet close to an X-ray star. A layer of heavy metals in their integument gives them some resistance to radiation.
They were engineered this way by a race that lusts for gold. The ants actually eat it, dissolve it in an internal equivalent of Aqua Regia, and plate it out on their integument.
The original species was much less discriminating and would use lead, cadmium, platinum, osmium -- almost any heavy nucleus.
Periodically the engineers land and release a pheromone that brings the ants to collection jars where they are flash burned, and the metal taken for further processing.
answered yesterday
Sherwood BotsfordSherwood Botsford
6,930733
6,930733
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
$begingroup$
this is pretty much "damned clever" !
$endgroup$
– Fattie
21 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Gold helps with their Farming
They don't bring gold to the surface and "throw it outside", but they could bring it into their fungus farms, where it could either:
- Repel harmful bacteria or organisms that would otherwise harm their farms.
- Attract & grow beneficial bacteria or organisms.
Some metals in our world exhibit an oligodynamic effect ("a chemical substance or microorganism intended to destroy, deter, render harmless, or exert a controlling effect on any harmful organism by chemical or biological means" [1]), including gold.
Apparently stainless steel is terrible at inhibiting bacteria, while brass would be much safer, in a hospital for example.
Some ants in our world have been farming fungus for millions of years, and apparently some people are wondering how they manage to avoid devastation by disease or parasites (like what happened to the Big Mike bananas).
And so in this other world there could be ants that farm a particular type of crop that either thrives on or around gold, or the gold repels a particularly nasty organism that would otherwise devastate their crops.
[The gold might not even affect their crop directly, but could be a link in a chain, like preventing a bacteria that would feed another fungus, that would feed another organism or predator, that would destroy the ants' crop or the ants themselves. Imagine a truffle-hunting pig (or elephant) that destroys everything in it's search.]
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Gold helps with their Farming
They don't bring gold to the surface and "throw it outside", but they could bring it into their fungus farms, where it could either:
- Repel harmful bacteria or organisms that would otherwise harm their farms.
- Attract & grow beneficial bacteria or organisms.
Some metals in our world exhibit an oligodynamic effect ("a chemical substance or microorganism intended to destroy, deter, render harmless, or exert a controlling effect on any harmful organism by chemical or biological means" [1]), including gold.
Apparently stainless steel is terrible at inhibiting bacteria, while brass would be much safer, in a hospital for example.
Some ants in our world have been farming fungus for millions of years, and apparently some people are wondering how they manage to avoid devastation by disease or parasites (like what happened to the Big Mike bananas).
And so in this other world there could be ants that farm a particular type of crop that either thrives on or around gold, or the gold repels a particularly nasty organism that would otherwise devastate their crops.
[The gold might not even affect their crop directly, but could be a link in a chain, like preventing a bacteria that would feed another fungus, that would feed another organism or predator, that would destroy the ants' crop or the ants themselves. Imagine a truffle-hunting pig (or elephant) that destroys everything in it's search.]
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Gold helps with their Farming
They don't bring gold to the surface and "throw it outside", but they could bring it into their fungus farms, where it could either:
- Repel harmful bacteria or organisms that would otherwise harm their farms.
- Attract & grow beneficial bacteria or organisms.
Some metals in our world exhibit an oligodynamic effect ("a chemical substance or microorganism intended to destroy, deter, render harmless, or exert a controlling effect on any harmful organism by chemical or biological means" [1]), including gold.
Apparently stainless steel is terrible at inhibiting bacteria, while brass would be much safer, in a hospital for example.
Some ants in our world have been farming fungus for millions of years, and apparently some people are wondering how they manage to avoid devastation by disease or parasites (like what happened to the Big Mike bananas).
And so in this other world there could be ants that farm a particular type of crop that either thrives on or around gold, or the gold repels a particularly nasty organism that would otherwise devastate their crops.
[The gold might not even affect their crop directly, but could be a link in a chain, like preventing a bacteria that would feed another fungus, that would feed another organism or predator, that would destroy the ants' crop or the ants themselves. Imagine a truffle-hunting pig (or elephant) that destroys everything in it's search.]
$endgroup$
Gold helps with their Farming
They don't bring gold to the surface and "throw it outside", but they could bring it into their fungus farms, where it could either:
- Repel harmful bacteria or organisms that would otherwise harm their farms.
- Attract & grow beneficial bacteria or organisms.
Some metals in our world exhibit an oligodynamic effect ("a chemical substance or microorganism intended to destroy, deter, render harmless, or exert a controlling effect on any harmful organism by chemical or biological means" [1]), including gold.
Apparently stainless steel is terrible at inhibiting bacteria, while brass would be much safer, in a hospital for example.
Some ants in our world have been farming fungus for millions of years, and apparently some people are wondering how they manage to avoid devastation by disease or parasites (like what happened to the Big Mike bananas).
And so in this other world there could be ants that farm a particular type of crop that either thrives on or around gold, or the gold repels a particularly nasty organism that would otherwise devastate their crops.
[The gold might not even affect their crop directly, but could be a link in a chain, like preventing a bacteria that would feed another fungus, that would feed another organism or predator, that would destroy the ants' crop or the ants themselves. Imagine a truffle-hunting pig (or elephant) that destroys everything in it's search.]
answered yesterday
Xen2050Xen2050
1,312414
1,312414
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Dummy gold war
They are exceptionally clever ants. When they find gold, they plant it on the anthill of they enemy and wait for a human to see it and destroy their enemy.
Very effective.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Dummy gold war
They are exceptionally clever ants. When they find gold, they plant it on the anthill of they enemy and wait for a human to see it and destroy their enemy.
Very effective.
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Dummy gold war
They are exceptionally clever ants. When they find gold, they plant it on the anthill of they enemy and wait for a human to see it and destroy their enemy.
Very effective.
$endgroup$
Dummy gold war
They are exceptionally clever ants. When they find gold, they plant it on the anthill of they enemy and wait for a human to see it and destroy their enemy.
Very effective.
answered yesterday
LegiseyLegisey
3,1861526
3,1861526
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
add a comment |
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
1
1
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
Humans are common enough around the globe, I'm almost kind of surprised no animal has evolved something like this already if it wasn't for the fact evolution normally moves so slow, and drawing humans attention at all is probably worse than drawing them more to your enemy colony.
$endgroup$
– liljoshu
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
@liljoshu some animals have "evolved" to get help from humans, not in the limited "destroy my enemies" way, but in the "give me shelter & warmth & food" way, like dogs & cats
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
Quotation marks on the "evolved" part in @Xen2050's comment, since that development has been heavily guided by human hands through selective breeding.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
$begingroup$
@Kapten-N True, especially for dogs, but there was probably a "0-day exploit" of wild animals hanging around people for food (table scraps, bones, mice/rats). And cats still look & act a lot like their wild counterparts, aside from slightly less biting & scratching they may not have been bred to be very different, and domestic cats can still basically "run away" & go feral again easily, I doubt a chihuahua would fare well on it's own. [Original quotations were because it's unclear if learning a new trick to make others fight is really "evolving"]
$endgroup$
– Xen2050
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Ants (of any size) communicate largely through pheromones - everything from mating to directions. As it happens, these ants also communicate through pheromones, but something about properties unique to gold either scrambles or removes the pheromone signals. Instinctively realizing that gold, therefore, is quite dangerous, the ants would thus attempt to remove the gold from their burrows, and depending on the strength of the effect, they may even hunt for gold and collect it to keep from being influenced.
Normal ants often have "garbage rooms" where they store their dead, as well as other garbage produced by the hill and its occupants, which would make a fine place to store excavated gold. They may even try to protect this gold, as their instincts have taught them that other creatures can use the gold to disorganize them.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Ants (of any size) communicate largely through pheromones - everything from mating to directions. As it happens, these ants also communicate through pheromones, but something about properties unique to gold either scrambles or removes the pheromone signals. Instinctively realizing that gold, therefore, is quite dangerous, the ants would thus attempt to remove the gold from their burrows, and depending on the strength of the effect, they may even hunt for gold and collect it to keep from being influenced.
Normal ants often have "garbage rooms" where they store their dead, as well as other garbage produced by the hill and its occupants, which would make a fine place to store excavated gold. They may even try to protect this gold, as their instincts have taught them that other creatures can use the gold to disorganize them.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Ants (of any size) communicate largely through pheromones - everything from mating to directions. As it happens, these ants also communicate through pheromones, but something about properties unique to gold either scrambles or removes the pheromone signals. Instinctively realizing that gold, therefore, is quite dangerous, the ants would thus attempt to remove the gold from their burrows, and depending on the strength of the effect, they may even hunt for gold and collect it to keep from being influenced.
Normal ants often have "garbage rooms" where they store their dead, as well as other garbage produced by the hill and its occupants, which would make a fine place to store excavated gold. They may even try to protect this gold, as their instincts have taught them that other creatures can use the gold to disorganize them.
$endgroup$
Ants (of any size) communicate largely through pheromones - everything from mating to directions. As it happens, these ants also communicate through pheromones, but something about properties unique to gold either scrambles or removes the pheromone signals. Instinctively realizing that gold, therefore, is quite dangerous, the ants would thus attempt to remove the gold from their burrows, and depending on the strength of the effect, they may even hunt for gold and collect it to keep from being influenced.
Normal ants often have "garbage rooms" where they store their dead, as well as other garbage produced by the hill and its occupants, which would make a fine place to store excavated gold. They may even try to protect this gold, as their instincts have taught them that other creatures can use the gold to disorganize them.
answered yesterday
ArmanXArmanX
10.1k32542
10.1k32542
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
$begingroup$
This answer sounds good, but it seems very unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, gold is a pretty inert material, i.e. it doesn't really react with most other substances. Thus it shouldn't really have any effect on ant pheromones either.
$endgroup$
– Kapten-N
yesterday
add a comment |
$begingroup$
It's a result of Darwinian evolution. Ant colonies that expelled gold to the surface, for whatever reasons, naturally attracted humans to them. Humans have a proclivity for carrying food and water with them when they journey through the desert. Gold-laden dirt would be relatively heavy, so humans intending to collect the dirt and return it to civilization for refining would tend to leave an equivalent amount of mass behind. This jetsam would frequently contain consumables such as food and water that would no longer be needed due to the interrupted travel plans of the fortunate discoverer. Those ant colonies would be more likely to successfully spread deeper into areas of desert that would otherwise be too inhospitable for them.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
It's a result of Darwinian evolution. Ant colonies that expelled gold to the surface, for whatever reasons, naturally attracted humans to them. Humans have a proclivity for carrying food and water with them when they journey through the desert. Gold-laden dirt would be relatively heavy, so humans intending to collect the dirt and return it to civilization for refining would tend to leave an equivalent amount of mass behind. This jetsam would frequently contain consumables such as food and water that would no longer be needed due to the interrupted travel plans of the fortunate discoverer. Those ant colonies would be more likely to successfully spread deeper into areas of desert that would otherwise be too inhospitable for them.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
It's a result of Darwinian evolution. Ant colonies that expelled gold to the surface, for whatever reasons, naturally attracted humans to them. Humans have a proclivity for carrying food and water with them when they journey through the desert. Gold-laden dirt would be relatively heavy, so humans intending to collect the dirt and return it to civilization for refining would tend to leave an equivalent amount of mass behind. This jetsam would frequently contain consumables such as food and water that would no longer be needed due to the interrupted travel plans of the fortunate discoverer. Those ant colonies would be more likely to successfully spread deeper into areas of desert that would otherwise be too inhospitable for them.
$endgroup$
It's a result of Darwinian evolution. Ant colonies that expelled gold to the surface, for whatever reasons, naturally attracted humans to them. Humans have a proclivity for carrying food and water with them when they journey through the desert. Gold-laden dirt would be relatively heavy, so humans intending to collect the dirt and return it to civilization for refining would tend to leave an equivalent amount of mass behind. This jetsam would frequently contain consumables such as food and water that would no longer be needed due to the interrupted travel plans of the fortunate discoverer. Those ant colonies would be more likely to successfully spread deeper into areas of desert that would otherwise be too inhospitable for them.
answered yesterday
dhinson919dhinson919
49015
49015
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Their large size is the key.
These very large ants will only dig their mounds out of the sides of mountains, hills and cliffs. The geographical area contains a large deposits of quartz over several square miles, and there is less chance of a tunnel collapse inside a quartz mountain.
Gold is found in quartz deposits, and the ants can dig out the gold far easier than quartz because it's a soft metal.
So where there are ants, there is gold by the entrance to their quartz caves.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Their large size is the key.
These very large ants will only dig their mounds out of the sides of mountains, hills and cliffs. The geographical area contains a large deposits of quartz over several square miles, and there is less chance of a tunnel collapse inside a quartz mountain.
Gold is found in quartz deposits, and the ants can dig out the gold far easier than quartz because it's a soft metal.
So where there are ants, there is gold by the entrance to their quartz caves.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Their large size is the key.
These very large ants will only dig their mounds out of the sides of mountains, hills and cliffs. The geographical area contains a large deposits of quartz over several square miles, and there is less chance of a tunnel collapse inside a quartz mountain.
Gold is found in quartz deposits, and the ants can dig out the gold far easier than quartz because it's a soft metal.
So where there are ants, there is gold by the entrance to their quartz caves.
$endgroup$
Medieval bestiaries describe a creature, a type of desert-dwelling ant that digs for gold. It was also said to be the size of a fox, but I'll ignore that in this question.
Their large size is the key.
These very large ants will only dig their mounds out of the sides of mountains, hills and cliffs. The geographical area contains a large deposits of quartz over several square miles, and there is less chance of a tunnel collapse inside a quartz mountain.
Gold is found in quartz deposits, and the ants can dig out the gold far easier than quartz because it's a soft metal.
So where there are ants, there is gold by the entrance to their quartz caves.
answered 9 hours ago
cgTagcgTag
1,5251418
1,5251418
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Worldbuilding Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f139922%2fplausible-reason-for-gold-digging-ant%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
$begingroup$
First I googled "ant + gold" , no result then for no good reason I tried "dog + gold" no good result!
$endgroup$
– user6760
yesterday
2
$begingroup$
I'll not find it quickly but one of Orson Scott Card's spin-off short stories from the Ender World universe is describing gold-digging insects (bugs, these were not ants). They were though artificially altered (normally they were digging and "digesting" some other mineral that was becoming their shell material).
$endgroup$
– Ister
yesterday
5
$begingroup$
Did a double take. I read: "Plausible reason for a gold-digging aunt"
$endgroup$
– Scott Milner
11 hours ago